Sunday, October 24, 2004

Pitching for the Yanks: Too Much to Handle?

An ESPN.com writer pointed out that Tom Gordon was so overwhelmed by the pressure in Game 6 of the ALCS that he threw up in the bullpen. Seems like Gordon is the latest casualty to fall to the pressure of pitching for the Yanks. And with the casualties mounting over the last few years, it seems like more pitchers will do like Greg Maddux in '92 and pass up on a chance to go to the Bronx.

It all started with Kenny Rogers back in '96. Rogers was awful in New York, but has done well in Texas and Minnesota. But back then, guys like Jimmy Key were able to deal with it. Seemed like it wasn't a big deal at the time.

Then in '00, there was Denny Neagle, whose experience in the Bronx was only 2nd-worst to his tenure with the Rockies. Jay Witasick was solid for the Padres in the beginning of '01, then morphed into Ed Whitson after joining the Yanks.

After that the list gets longer. Weaver. Contreras. Gabe White. Felix Heredia. The latest? Javier Vazquez and Tom Gordon. All of the above have succeeded at some point for another club. But Yankee pressure got the best of them. And it seems that this pressure is reaching the point where many players don't want to join the Yankees.

Carl Pavano, one of the top arms on this year's free-agent market, has said that he doesn't want to sign with the Junkees. And even if the Yankees dangle enough $$$ to get a guy like Eric Milton, who's to say he'll do well in the Bronx after stints in Minny and Philly?

Seems like if you want to do well for the Yanks these days, you better get your ego ready. The aloof Mike Mussina and surly El Duque fit nicely with the Yankees. Maybe Jon Lieber is an exception to this rule. But for most pitchers, it's "enter at the risk of your sanity." And ask the Orioles of the late '90's about trying to win with lots of egos on the team. Doesn't work.

Hitters don't suffer as much (but don't forget Chuck Knoblauch and Rondell White), simply because they're not in the spotlight like the pitchers. After all, a struggling hitter usually has 8 other guys to bail him out. But a stinky pitcher is out there all alone on the mound.

With Yankee craziness, desperation, and pressure at an all-time high, Yankee Stadium is gonna start looking about as appealing as Coors Field to free-agent pitchers. Once again, the madness of King George may come back to hurt the Yankees.

3 comments:

PizzaBagel said...

Don't forget Ted Lilly, now with the Blue Jays, who has done well since leaving the Junkees - certainly a lot better than when he was with them.

Anonymous said...

In Lilly's case, I disagree. He had a few good starts before he was traded, including a near no-hitter against Seattle. George only traded him because he had a bad start against the Mets.

Also, Lilly was younger then. I think he's developed somewhat.

COnsidering that the Yanks got Weaver in exchange and then Brownie, I think trading Lilly was another bonehead move by Cashman.

Anonymous said...

In Lilly's case, I disagree. He had a few good starts before he was traded, including a near no-hitter against Seattle. George only traded him because he had a bad start against the Mets.

Also, Lilly was younger then. I think he's developed somewhat.

COnsidering that the Yanks got Weaver in exchange and then Brownie, I think trading Lilly was another bonehead move by Cashman.